Mining in Bolivia: Current State of the Industry

Historical Context and Development of Mining Activity in Bolivia

Mining in Bolivia is as old as the country's history, but its modern framework took real shape under the influence of several pivotal events in Bolivian history. The discovery of the Cerro Rico mountain in Potosí brought Bolivia to international prominence as a mining centre back in the 16th century. For a long period, this silver mine was the most important supplier of this metal in the world because it is calculated that 60,000 metric tons were extracted from this metal within the XVI-XVIII centuries. However, this wealth was basically used by the colonial powers, while the population forced to work in labour passed through extreme hardship.

Independent Bolivia continued to be based on mining, particularly tin, which turned out to be its leading export product by the end of the 19th century. The rise of so-called tin barons, like Simón Patiño, transformed Bolivia into one of the major tin producers in the world. Nevertheless, this industry had highly centralised ownership in the hands of a few very powerful oligarchies, bringing serious inequality and social unrest.

The middle of the 20th century became a very important milestone. 1952 following a revolution, the Bolivian government nationalised the mining industry by forming the state-owned enterprise COMIBOL- Corporación Minera de Bolivia. This was to redistribute wealth and democratise the benefits of mining. COMIBOL dominated Bolivia's mining industry for decades, controlling most large-scale mining operations. Inefficient use, lack of investment, and the instability in commodity prices finally weakened that performance and opened up the market to other players.

Current Structure of Bolivia's Mining Sector

Today, Bolivia's mining sector consists of large and small state-owned enterprises, private foreign and domestic companies, cooperative miners, and a multitude of small-scale informal miners. It reflects the variety within the complex economic and political environments that have shaped Bolivia through the ages and the diversity of its mineral resources.

COMIBOL, the national mining corporation, still plays a central role in the mining industry of Bolivia, although its influence is much less than at its peak in the mid-20th century. The corporation operates a number of important mines, the most notable of which is the Huanuni tin mine, one of the largest in Bolivia. However, over recent decades, COMIBOL has struggled with inefficiencies, corruption, and lack of access to capital to invest in modern mine technology and exploration.

Given that, since the 1990s, an effort to revitalise the corporation has been underway, especially under the administration of President Evo Morales, 2006-2019, who planned to reassert state control over key industries. Morales forwarded a resource-nationalist agenda intended to increase state revenue from mining and renegotiate contracts with foreign investors to ensure better gain in Bolivia. Results have fallen between ambivalence and scepticism since state operations have struggled with outdated equipment, disputes over labour rights, and environmental concerns.

Foreign and Domestic Private Mining Companies

Besides COMIBOL, Bolivia's mining industry also involves several foreign and domestic private firms that are largely involved in the exploitation of key minerals like zinc, silver, and lithium. One of the largest foreign mining firms operating in Bolivia is San Cristóbal Mining, owned by Japan's Sumitomo Corporation. The San Cristóbal mine is one of the largest zinc and silver producers in Latin America, located in the department of Potosí. Most foreign-invested, this project employs the most up-to-date mining techniques that few other country operations enjoy. More recently, Bolivia has also focused highly on lithium reserves, which are among the largest in the world. The Salar de Uyuni, located in the high Andes, hosts enormous lithium resources, a critical component for electric vehicle batteries and other renewable energy technologies. The Morales administration was under popular political pressure to maintain this strategic industry for national ownership and, as such, pushed state-controlled joint ventures and was more decidedly cool on foreign investment. For years, the state enterprise Yacimientos de Litio Bolivianos has been at the core of Bolivia's lithium strategy, yet it is, time after time, unable to fulfil ambitious production targets due to technological and infrastructural limitations.

The Bolivian policy on foreign investment in mining has seesawed between periods of openness and phases of resource nationalism. As a result, some international firms have hung back, not least because of the regulatory complexities and risks inherent in investing in the country. Foreign companies remain crucial investors in the mining sector of Bolivia where significant investment is required in infrastructure and technology.

Cooperative Mining in Bolivia

The most peculiar and socially relevant feature of Bolivia's mining sector is the pre-eminence of mining cooperatives. These are small-scale miners organised under a collective structure, making up the major part of Bolivian mineral production, particularly in tin and silver. The basis of mining cooperatives in Bolivia has roots tracing back to the 1950s when nationalisation displaced many workers to form cooperatives so as to continue mining.

In the past decades, especially with COMIBOL's decline in influence and the ups and downs of global demand for minerals, the number of cooperatives has increased significantly. Nowadays, there are thousands of mining cooperatives around Bolivia, employing tens of thousands in jobs that are often precarious.

While cooperatives are a means to create employment and give Bolivians opportunities, they face their set of challenges. Many of the cooperative miners toil in very hazardous conditions without much access to modern technology or safety equipment. Besides that, the relationship between the cooperatives and the government has been argumentative at one point or another. Cooperatives do enjoy huge political weight and are one of the key voting blocs; their informal, loosely regulated nature has caused environmental degradation and questions on revenue collection. Co-op miners do not always have to bear the same taxes and are subject to similar regulations as private companies. A host of questions have arisen over the years with respect to this issue, touching on the concerns of fairness and the long-term viability of the sector.

In the last few years, clashes between cooperatives and the state have become more grave, and the points of dispute have included labour rights and environmental controls. The Morales government tried to formalise the cooperatives even more and, in parallel with this, to improve working conditions, all with limited success so far. Most cooperatives strongly oppose greater government regulation, fearing that this would reduce their autonomy and profitability.

Artisanal and Small-Scale Mining

Another important constituent of Bolivia's mining industry is the informal and small-scale mining sector. Single miners or small groups usually carry out mining activities in the informal sector without any license or permit. Most of the time, these miners take advantage of the deposits that have marginal values or sites of abandoned mines, thus contributing to the extraction of gold, tin, and tungsten.

A lot of challenges emanate from Bolivia's government against the informal mining sector. The informal miners mine in usual environmentally sensitive areas, bringing about deforestation, water contamination, and soil degradation. Because of the use of mercury, small-scale gold mining represents a particular concern for the health of miners and their communities. Furthermore, the conditions in which informal miners normally work are usually without basic protection of labour or standards of safety, leading to a very high rate of accidents and labour exploitation.

Formalisation of informal mining has taken place, but it is a very gradual process. It is a sector that gives livelihoods to so many poor Bolivians, and because of that, it is politically sensitive. The government has put in place different programs to try to get informal miners into co-ops or to follow regulatory frameworks, but in general, enforcement is spotty, with many miners continuing to operate extra-legally.

Lithium has drawn the most and increasing focus in recent times, as this is a crucial component of batteries in electric automobiles and renewable energy storage. Bolivian resources are among the largest in the world and concentrated in the so-called Salar de Uyuni. While demand goes up day by day, it's just waiting in the wings for Bolivia to start playing a major role in the global market.

Mining in Bolivia: Lithium Potential and its Strategic Importance

However, Bolivia's lithium industry's development has proved slow and challenging. While the state-run lithium company, YLB, has been tasked with managing the country's lithium resources, it has struggled to move beyond pilot projects to large-scale production. Bolivia's insistence on maintaining majority control over lithium projects has deterred some foreign investors, who are willing to commit significant capital with greater operational control.

Bolivia's lithium ambitions also face a host of technological challenges. Because of the high concentration of magnesium in Bolivia's brines, extracting lithium from the brine at the Salar de Uyuni is more difficult and costly compared to other countries such as Chile or Argentina. This has forced the government to invest heavily in research and development to develop better methods of extraction.

Bolivia's lithium policy has also been in line with its broader political and economic goals. Morales' administration wanted to ensure that the exploitation of lithium would not only generate income but also contribute to the development of a nationally based battery-manufacturing business. However, this ambitious dream has yet to be fulfilled, and Bolivia still holds a relatively minor position in the global lithium market (see also: Critical minerals strategy).

Issues of Environment and Society

The mining industry in Bolivia faces serious environmental and social challenges. Environmental degradation from mining operations is extreme, including deforestation, water contamination, and soil erosion, particularly around cities like Potosí and Oruro. The use of toxic chemicals in gold mining-mercury, particularly cyanide, raises public health and long-term sustainability concerns regarding the mining operations (read also about responsible mining in Latin America).

Besides that, Bolivian mining has been repeatedly associated with deplorable labour conditions. Many miners, especially those employed in cooperatives or within the informal sector of the economy, work in hazardous conditions with limited access to safety equipment or health care. In some regions, child labour and conditions of labour exploitation continue unabated.

Another important consequence of mining is its social impact. Most of the mining centres in Bolivia are expected to reflect high levels of poverty and social inequality. While mining brings both employment and economic opportunities, not all the wealth resulting from mineral extraction has been equitably distributed, which again has brought about social tensions and protests.

FAQ

What are the main minerals produced by Bolivia's mining industry?

Bolivia's mining industry is primarily focused on the extraction of tin, silver, zinc, and lithium. Historically, tin has been one of the country's most significant mineral exports, with Bolivia being a leading global producer. The country is also rich in silver, particularly from the famous Cerro Rico mine in Potosí. Additionally, Bolivia is a major producer of zinc, largely extracted from large mining operations such as the San Cristóbal mine. In recent years, lithium has emerged as a highly valuable resource, with Bolivia holding some of the largest lithium reserves in the world, located in the Salar de Uyuni salt flats.

What is the role of mining cooperatives in Bolivia's mining industry?

Mining cooperatives play a crucial role in Bolivia's mining sector, particularly in the extraction of tin and silver. These cooperatives are made up of small-scale miners who work collectively, often in hazardous conditions, without the same level of technological support as larger companies. Cooperatives are a major source of employment for many Bolivians, but they also face challenges related to safety, environmental regulations, and labour conditions. Despite these challenges, they remain politically influential and a key part of the country's mining landscape.

TAKEAWAY

Today, the Bolivian mining sector is influenced by an interplay of historical legacies, diversified minerals, and ever-changing political and economic scenarios. State-owned companies like COMIBOL, foreign and domestic private ones, mining cooperatives, and informal miners make different contributions that shape Bolivia's position as a significant world producer of minerals such as tin, silver, zinc, and lithium.

However, Bolivian mining also faces a host of challenges. Perpetual issues of environmental degradation, social inequality, and labour disputes are major concerns that the government and industry players must consider. Further, even though there is great potential arising in newly emerging sectors like lithium, overcoming the technological, financial, and political barriers to tapping into that resource will take time.

Whether Bolivia will continue its economic growth with consideration for social and environmental sustainability will define long-term success in its mining industry. Rich in mineral wealth, Bolivia is a country of immense promise in the global mining landscape, yet its future lies in how effectively it manages the challenges and opportunities ahead.

Delve into one of our core topics: Miner Safety

Sources:

(1) https://insightcrime.org/investigations/gold-mining-state-sanctioned-scourge-bolivia/

(2) https://www.responsiblemines.org/en/2023/10/the-challenges-of-small-scale-tin-mining-in-bolivia-peru-and-brazil/

Author

Michal Wozniakowski-Zehenter, Marketing Manager

Michal Wozniakowski-Zehenter is an experienced marketing and project management professional. He spent most of his career on projects with a strong focus on digital marketing and event management. He is a very active voice representing offshore and mining industries through social media channels. Michal writes mainly about offshore oil and gas, renewable energy, mining and tunnelling. Compiling and sharing the knowledge within industries is one of his goals.

Find here a selection of his articles.